How to Retarget Clicked Prospects for 2X Conversions

Priyadharshini
· 4 min read
Send by email
Retarget clicked prospects using CRM workflows and double your conversion potential

In today's competitive digital landscape, acquiring new leads is only half the battle. The real challenge—and opportunity—lies in effectively converting prospects who have already shown interest in your business. Retargeting these "clicked prospects" can dramatically increase your conversion rates, often doubling your results with the same lead pool.

Why Clicked Prospects Are Your Most Valuable Asset

Prospects who have clicked on your ads, visited your website, or engaged with your content have already demonstrated interest in your solutions. They're familiar with your brand and have taken a first step in the buyer's journey. According to recent research, these warm leads are 70% more likely to convert when properly retargeted compared to cold traffic.

The data is compelling:

  • Retargeted ads achieve 10x higher click-through rates than standard display ads
  • Website visitors who are retargeted are 43% more likely to convert
  • Effective retargeting can reduce customer acquisition costs by up to 50%

Let's explore the strategies that will help you double conversions from these high-potential prospects.

1. Implement an Omnichannel Retargeting Strategy

The most successful retargeting campaigns don't rely on a single platform. Instead, they create an "omnipresent" experience where your brand appears wherever your prospects spend time online.

The Omnipresent Advantage

When prospects see your brand across multiple platforms, it creates a perception of authority and builds trust through familiarity. This approach dramatically increases touchpoints without appearing intrusive.

Implementation steps:

  1. Install tracking pixels across all major platforms (Meta, Google, LinkedIn, etc.)
  2. Sync your CRM data with advertising platforms to create custom audiences
  3. Develop platform-specific creative that maintains consistent messaging
  4. Set appropriate frequency caps to prevent ad fatigue

Platform mix recommendation:

  • Facebook/Instagram for social engagement
  • Google Display Network for broad reach
  • YouTube for educational content
  • LinkedIn for B2B prospects

2. Create a Strategic Nurture Sequence

Rather than showing the same ad repeatedly, develop a strategic sequence that guides prospects through their decision-making process.

The 5-Step Nurture Sequence

Step 1: Problem Amplifier

  • Remind prospects of the problem they're trying to solve
  • Emphasize the cost of inaction or staying with the status quo
  • Use emotional triggers that resonate with their pain points

Step 2: Solution Introducer

  • Present your solution as the ideal answer to their problem
  • Focus on key benefits rather than features
  • Include social proof elements like testimonials or case studies

Step 3: Credibility Builder

  • Showcase your expertise and authority in the field
  • Share client success stories and results
  • Highlight industry recognition or certifications

Step 4: Objection Crusher

  • Proactively address common objections
  • Provide guarantees or risk-reversal elements
  • Answer frequently asked questions

Step 5: FOMO Creator

  • Create urgency with limited- time offers
  • Emphasize scarcity if applicable
  • Provide a clear, compelling call to action

3. Leverage Dynamic Retargeting for Personalization at Scale

Dynamic retargeting automatically shows prospects the specific products or content they've previously viewed, creating a highly personalized experience without manual effort.

Implementation Strategy:

  1. Set up product or content feeds that connect to your advertising platforms
  2. Create dynamic ad templates that automatically populate with relevant items
  3. Segment audiences based on engagement depth (casual browsers vs. cart abandoners)
  4. Implement cross-sell and upsell logic to increase average order value

4. Optimize for Cross-Device Tracking and Attribution

Today's buyers switch between multiple devices during their purchase journey. Effective retargeting requires seamless tracking across these touchpoints.

Best Practices:

  1. Implement unified ID solutions that work across devices
  2. Use first-party data collection methods that are privacy-compliant
  3. Set up proper attribution models that account for multiple touchpoints
  4. Leverage CRM integration to maintain a complete view of the customer journey

5. Implement Behavioral Segmentation for Precision Targeting

Not all clicked prospects are equal. Segmenting them based on their specific behaviors allows for much more effective retargeting.

Key Segments to Target:

  1. High-Intent Visitors - Those who viewed pricing pages or product specifications
  2. Cart/Form Abandoners - Prospects who began but didn't complete a conversion action
  3. Content Engagers - Those who consumed multiple pieces of content but didn't convert
  4. Return Visitors - Prospects who have visited your site multiple times
  5. Time-Based Segments - Recent visitors vs. those who haven't returned in weeks

6. Implement Continuous Testing and Optimization

The most successful retargeting campaigns are those that continuously evolve based on performance data.

Key Elements to Test:

  1. Creative variations - Test different images, videos, and copy
  2. Offer types - Discounts vs. free trials vs. content upgrades
  3. Call-to-action language - Test different CTAs to find what resonates
  4. Landing page experiences - Ensure post-click experiences match ad promises
  5. Frequency and timing - Find the optimal exposure pattern

Conclusion: The Untapped Goldmine in Your Business

Most businesses are sitting on a goldmine of potential revenue in their existing lead database. By implementing strategic retargeting to these clicked prospects, you can often double your conversions without acquiring a single new lead.

The key is to appear everywhere your prospects go online with messaging that addresses their specific needs and objections at each stage of the buyer's journey. When done correctly, this approach not only increases conversions but also builds brand authority and trust.

Remember: Your existing leads are not a junkyard—they're a goldmine waiting to be tapped. With the right retargeting strategy, you can extract significantly more value from the leads you already have.

Transform Your Clicked Prospects into Customers Today →

"The fortune is in the follow-up. The most successful businesses aren't those that attract the most prospects, but those that convert the highest percentage of prospects into customers." 

Written by Priyadharshini